See likes

See likes given/taken


Posts you liked

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5
Post info No. of Likes
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts
Hi guys,

I found thist threat yeasterday and I I read the whole thing because I want to order this same frame, thanks for all that cool information :).
My only thought is ,wich frame size would fit me better.? Comparing the geometry with my actual Scalpel Si in L, the carbonda frame is pretty big so I'm considering downsizing to M. What you guys think?
I am 1,83m tall and I usually have my saddle height at 77,5 cm (BB to top of the Saddle).
Anyone riding a M with more or less the same saddle height?

Thanks again and keep posting those cool bike pics!

I'm 185cm and I ride the L, with 60mm stem and flat bar. I would not want to ride a M that is for sure. L feels very perfect.

November 05, 2020, 04:29:21 AM
1
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts When i center the pictures on the rear bike axle, you can see that the geometry, wheelbase, angles, BB height etc. are very very different.
But saddle->handlebar length is the same => same "pedaling" position



The FM936 is a modern geometry, it should be riding hard, with short stem. Take a size L and downsize your stem  ;D

November 05, 2020, 01:15:07 PM
1
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts
Are you happy with sizing down? How does your build ride? Did you end up changing the stem or headset spacers to increase reach/stack?

I sized up and have no complaints.

Yeah, I'm definitely happy with the bike. I was worried it might be a bit small and I'd have to push seat back in rails or go longer stem. But the fit is fine with seat centred in the rails and a 50mm stem. The centre of the bars to seat measurement is within 5mm of my 2019 XL Commencal Meta TR, which has the same HTA, STA so it feels very similar to that bike, but weighs about 10lbs less and pedals like a hot damn! Looking forward to doing XCM with it.

November 13, 2020, 01:21:16 PM
1
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts
Hi Folks,
inspired by colt_seaver's building thread in a german forum, i spent the last days reading all 72 pages of this thread :o (who needs netflix? ;) )
I like the FM936 more and more... already have a spreadsheet set up to calculate price and weight of a bike based on this frame.

I stumbled across a few comments about poor climbing performance.
I am a fast tourer and marathon rider and my current "do it all" bike is a not-so-light carbon hardtail (IP-256SL if sb knows). I really like steep uphill challenges and eating altitude meters.
Problem is, i am a total coward going downhill: The smallest feel of sliding or the rear wheel getting light leads to a complete mental blockade. To overcome that, i think about using a more down-country or even trailbike-oriented bike. As i have a very long torso for my size, most common bikes on the market would be too short for me, so the FM936 should be just right for me.
Thing is, i don't really want to sacrifice uphill performance. So hands down, how much worse is the FM936's uphill performance compared to a hardtail?
Do you think the FM936 will meet my needs, i.e. giving me a fast touring resp. marathon bike with much more downhill confidence?

Is it worth the effort (money/weight) to have a rear shock remote lockout? I like standing up in the pedals for spontaneous give-it-all sprints. The only full suspension i rode the last years was a Giant Reign 2, wich was an absolute pain in the ass in this discipline (yes, different bike category).

Also, does sb have an idea how much weight is saved by opting for SL in size XL? Can i expect 200 g?
colt_seavers had 2182 g including rear axle for a standard XL.
I try to figure out where to save the most weight for the least money. Sub 11 kg with dropper post would be nice, but budget is limited.

A couple of answers for you in no particular order.
My current full squish (Evil Following MB) climbs better than my hard tail on 90% of the terrain I ride. Anything that isn't smooth, and the FS does better. Lots of rocky, rooty and rutted technical climbs where the FS does much better because it is so much better at maintaining tread contact. Set the suspension up correctly and I doubt you'd miss your HT on anything but the smoothest climbs.

 I have never used the lockout, even on the street or smooth fire roads. However, my XC racing buddies use remote lockouts and both swear by them.

Carbonda shows 150 g difference for the SL in size M. I doubt you'll get 200 on an XL and even if you did, you could probably save more weight spending that money elsewhere.

This bike will shock you with how much better it feels going down than the typical XC HT. The geometry gives it so much stability. It's not an enduro, but drop the seat and point it down and have fun.

Finally, you won't hit 11 kg with a dropper unless you have lots of really lite parts already, friends who will sell you really lite parts on the cheap or you spend a bunch of money. Limited budget and lite weight don't really go together. Budget Chiner lite weight wheels, tires and cassette alone will cost you about $1400, add in fork cost and you're already at $3k with the frame. Of course, if you wanted an 11 kg factory built bike with similar geometry, it would cost you much more, Transition Spur, XX1 size M, 11.2 kg, $9k. https://www.transitionbikes.com/Bikes_Spur.cfm



November 17, 2020, 11:13:04 AM
1
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts I am very happy with the behavior of this frame, it is what I was looking for for geometry.  Later we will change wheels, fork and cranks.
November 24, 2020, 02:49:32 PM
1
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts Just needs brakes bleeding and dropper cable adjustment, love it!!



November 28, 2020, 12:37:19 PM
1
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts
Thanks

But I want a shock with remote!  ;)

I just bought a SIDLuxe RL Solo Air (not debonair) compatible twistlock (remote).
I bought a 165x40mm to be safe (i am 63kg but aggressive riding...).
But 165x42,5mm is available.

https://www.bike24.com/p2397287.html

December 01, 2020, 07:06:45 AM
1
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts
No way! How many months is that now? :O
That's what you get if you want an SL BSA !

My two other friends got theirs last week.
The order was from end of June. But you know... Covid, airlines, ...  ???  :D

Here is a not so good picture of the orange one:

December 02, 2020, 10:45:48 AM
1
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts
I just asked them to take a picture of the shock they have in stock, arguing that 1 customer received the wrong shock and that Rockshox says there is no aftermarket remote shock. I don't want to pay for a return if they send the wrong shock.

I will let you know.
My order is still blocked for 1 week because 1 product is not in stock, hopefully I will solve it before shipment.

i wonder if a fox shock will work with the twist lock remote. it seems it might but im not sure yet .
https://forums.mtbr.com/shocks-suspension/possible-use-rockshox-twistloc-fox-suspension-1086651.html

The twistlock aparently has a 10mm cable pull. just need to find a suitable fox shock and confirm the cable pull needed it. 

Ive also emailed sram again asking if they have any shock in 165x40 with remote thats available after market. Also asked which bikes come with the 165x40 remote shock OEM...maybe could just order a "replacement" shock through a dealer. will post any info i get here

December 04, 2020, 05:20:15 AM
1
Re: Carbonda fm936 Thoughts
Hi Risckys,
Could you post a pic of your bike, please?

Sorry for the delay!




December 19, 2020, 12:00:30 PM
1