Chinertown

Other Resources => Component Deals & Selection => Topic started by: 1Sigma on July 12, 2021, 05:05:21 PM

Title: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on July 12, 2021, 05:05:21 PM
Received new wheels today - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Pillar 1420 spokes F24, R24
RD13 34T star ratchet hubs, center-lock disc
Purchased direct from manufacturer and not through Elite's retail channel, so no branding

Sine wave pattern ala Princeton Grit 4540

Comes in at a respectable 1519g for the pair.

Price, including shipping and duties: $615USD
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: RobertRinAustin on July 12, 2021, 10:07:00 PM
Those look good. Keep us updated on how they ride and hold up.
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Nickk2000 on July 13, 2021, 10:12:51 AM
Can you shoot the link where you got them? Love the sinusoidal.
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: curvenut on July 13, 2021, 03:07:43 PM
Nice !
How much cheaper when you buy directly to the manufactorer ?
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on July 13, 2021, 08:09:49 PM
Here is the link for the wheel, although they have some other nice sets, like a natural carbon lightweight set

https://xmcarbon.en.alibaba.com/product/1600247326063-815335396/New_arrivals_BWT_road_disc_wheelset_45mm_rim_depth_29mm_width_tubeless_700c_carbon_wheelset.html?spm=a2700.shop_plgr.41413.37.64296d3emYFFnw

Available with DT Swiss hubs, for a price of course.

Here is the same wheel on their retail site (Elite Wheels)
https://www.elite-wheel.com/elitewheels-bwt-aerodynamics-wheelset-45mm-rim-depth-tubeless-compatible-p3119055.html
$833 with Elite (RD) hubs and shipping. So, not including a potential duties hit $218 cheaper buying direct

I'll let you all know how they ride - apparently they hold up better under cross-winds.  Of course, I won't know until my dang frame arrives!
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: RobertRinAustin on July 13, 2021, 08:41:37 PM
I need some new MTB wheels for my AM831 coming soon I hope. Might give these guys a try.
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: carbonazza on July 14, 2021, 01:15:47 AM
Received new wheels today - Elite Wheels BWT Disc...

What is the offered advantage of that rim shape?
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on July 14, 2021, 01:54:14 PM
Apparently reduced drag, especially at different yaw angles, and less buffeting during cross-winds relative to standard toroidal shaped aero wheels.
Other knock on effects, the shallower areas use less material because they are shallower and apparently because less reinforcement is necessary resulting in thinner walls in the shallow areas, resulting I weight savings.... apparently

Haven't seen any independent studies, so it could all be baloney.


Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Nickk2000 on July 14, 2021, 03:56:33 PM
Apparently reduced drag, especially at different yaw angles, and less buffeting during cross-winds relative to standard toroidal shaped aero wheels.
Other knock on effects, the shallower areas use less material because they are shallower and apparently because less reinforcement is necessary resulting in thinner walls in the shallow areas, resulting I weight savings.... apparently

Haven't seen any independent studies, so it could all be baloney.

The sin shape does have benefits, princeton cw did release some numbers, this is just copying it.

As for weight, im gonna call bs on that. Weight is 1530 with dt350. You can get that with the normal shape at 50mm. I was hoping to see the 1400’s for them, then id be impressed. So right now theres a slight performance benefit but mostly looks, and those wheels are sure as hell pretty.
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on July 14, 2021, 04:41:07 PM
The sin shape does have benefits, princeton cw did release some numbers, this is just copying it.

As for weight, im gonna call bs on that. Weight is 1530 with dt350. You can get that with the normal shape at 50mm. I was hoping to see the 1400’s for them, then id be impressed. So right now theres a slight performance benefit but mostly looks, and those wheels are sure as hell pretty.

In fairness to Elite, they make no specific claims to weight savings due to the shape. I think Princeton makes that claim (or someone reviewing the Princeton time said that. I don't remember) 

I think the UNC model gets into the 1400s
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: curvenut on July 14, 2021, 09:55:41 PM
Here is the link for the wheel, although they have some other nice sets, like a natural carbon lightweight set

https://xmcarbon.en.alibaba.com/product/1600247326063-815335396/New_arrivals_BWT_road_disc_wheelset_45mm_rim_depth_29mm_width_tubeless_700c_carbon_wheelset.html?spm=a2700.shop_plgr.41413.37.64296d3emYFFnw

Available with DT Swiss hubs, for a price of course.

Here is the same wheel on their retail site (Elite Wheels)
https://www.elite-wheel.com/elitewheels-bwt-aerodynamics-wheelset-45mm-rim-depth-tubeless-compatible-p3119055.html
$833 with Elite (RD) hubs and shipping. So, not including a potential duties hit $218 cheaper buying direct

I'll let you all know how they ride - apparently they hold up better under cross-winds.  Of course, I won't know until my dang frame arrives!


 I just check the alibaba vendor,  it says  Type: Tubeless

but is it clincher compatible too ??   I am confused.
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on July 15, 2021, 07:17:56 AM

 I just check the alibaba vendor,  it says  Type: Tubeless

but is it clincher compatible too ??   I am confused.

TLDR: It's a tubeless ready(TR)/tubeless compatible(TC) rim (these terms are interchangeable)
Meaning that it has a rim profile capable of accommodating a tubeless tire, but will still take a clincher as well. 

In reality, most tubeless rims are actually TR
In fact, the difference between TR rim and a standard clincher is pretty small. To the point where some have success converting a clincher rim to tubeless.  YMMV.
The rim profile on the TR just helps a tubeless tire mate better with the rim for a tighter seal.

However, there are dedicated tubeless rims where the spoke holes are covered, and they have a special rim profile to mate with special tubeless tires to create a seal with tape or sealant  (eg UST tubeless).
This is not that type of wheel.
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Nickk2000 on July 15, 2021, 08:21:25 AM
To piggy back this, tubeless compatible wheels are hooked. You can get tubeless rims that are unhooked (hooked are called crotchet i think). Hookless tubeless rims can not fit a standard clincher. So make sure it contains a hook.
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on September 13, 2021, 02:15:16 PM
Short review. 

The RD13 hub is noisy as all hell!  I know some people love this, and I can see some cases where it is useful, but Elite was not lying when they gave the hub a sound score of 4/10
Had to install 6-bolt to centerlock adapters.  It would not fit over the rear wheel.  Can't tell if it was the machining on the adapters, or the hub.  Default logic says it was the cheaper part (the adapter)

This was my first time mounting tubeless, but it was super easy.  I am also the Michelin Power Road tire, which is apparently one of the easiest tubeless to mount. 

I have not had a chance to run these in crosswinds, so I cannot report on stability.
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: GilardiRT on September 13, 2021, 03:41:03 PM
Short review. 

The RD13 hub is noisy as all hell!  I know some people love this, and I can see some cases where it is useful, but Elite was not lying when they gave the hub a sound score of 4/10
Had to install 6-bolt to centerlock adapters.  It would not fit over the rear wheel.  Can't tell if it was the machining on the adapters, or the hub.  Default logic says it was the cheaper part (the adapter)

This was my first time mounting tubeless, but it was super easy.  I am also the Michelin Power Road tire, which is apparently one of the easiest tubeless to mount. 

I have not had a chance to run these in crosswinds, so I cannot report on stability.
I've ordered a set of ent disc, hope my hubs will be loud as yours, I would love that
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on September 13, 2021, 05:51:45 PM
I've ordered a set of ent disc, hope my hubs will be loud as yours, I would love that

If you got the ENT I am afraid your hubs will be silent.

Hubs =RD07
https://m.aliexpress.com/i/4000429562112.html?gatewayAdapt=Pc2Msite
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: curvenut on September 27, 2021, 11:55:48 AM
Here is the link for the wheel, although they have some other nice sets, like a natural carbon lightweight set

https://xmcarbon.en.alibaba.com/product/1600247326063-815335396/New_arrivals_BWT_road_disc_wheelset_45mm_rim_depth_29mm_width_tubeless_700c_carbon_wheelset.html?spm=a2700.shop_plgr.41413.37.64296d3emYFFnw

Available with DT Swiss hubs, for a price of course.


OMG the price is now 710$US ,  then add shipping, then tax probably ...
Inflation is steep in couple months
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: curvenut on September 27, 2021, 09:40:10 PM
If you got the ENT I am afraid your hubs will be silent.

Hubs =RD07
https://m.aliexpress.com/i/4000429562112.html?gatewayAdapt=Pc2Msite

Hi ,

 Wheredid you see the noise level of the R07 ?
 I cannot seethe dbsound level in the spec.

In fact I am looing for a quiet wheel from the vendor but they not not provide the DB noise level of the hub
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on September 28, 2021, 10:10:15 AM
Hi ,

 Wheredid you see the noise level of the R07 ?
 I cannot seethe dbsound level in the spec.

In fact I am looing for a quiet wheel from the vendor but they not not provide the DB noise level of the hub

If you follow the link below, it goes to a product page specifically for the RD07.
There should be a radar chart showing the different properties of the hub


Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Charltonfan1 on September 30, 2021, 09:12:59 AM
Hi OP,

How are they riding? Wasn't sure whether to go for the BWS or BWT model - unsure of the difference? I need the Rim break version

Thanks
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Nicoloc on September 30, 2021, 12:16:47 PM
the Elitewheel product line is quite difficult o understand.
If someone is able to tell differences between the various product, i'm interested in.
Nicoloc
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: curvenut on September 30, 2021, 12:49:02 PM
the Elitewheel product line is quite difficult o understand.
If someone is able to tell differences between the various product, i'm interested in.
Nicoloc

 Id like to known too !

I read all their wheels specs and still dont known the difference between all wheels  (excepth the specs on size and weight)
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on September 30, 2021, 02:23:46 PM
Hi OP,

How are they riding? Wasn't sure whether to go for the BWS or BWT model - unsure of the difference? I need the Rim break version

Thanks

The BWS is a Zipp-inspired saw-tooth design, while the BWT is a Princeton Carbon-inspired sinusoidal design
In both cases, the profiles are not as aggressive as the wheelsets they resemble (e.g the BWT is 45mm at the deep sections and 42mm in the shallow sections, while the Princeton Grit 4540 is 45mm and 40mm)

A lot of the designs look super similar, but it appears that some are just variations on a theme (different hubs, different spokes, different depths, and lighter or heavier rim weights), while others have novel features, such as the BWS and BWT
 
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Charltonfan1 on October 01, 2021, 01:27:46 AM
Thanks for the info

How are yours riding?
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on October 01, 2021, 11:46:49 AM
Thanks for the info

How are yours riding?

Take this with a pinch of salt, a my prior set were a used mismatch low-end Shimano and Alex Rims combo, with cup-cone bearings...

That being disclosed, I am loving them.  Tubeless set-up was a breeze - it was my first time, but I do own a compressor....
They rolled true out of the box and seem fast.

I say "seem", as I am riding these on a new build, which is on an aero frame and a full 10lbs lighter than my commuter.  So I cannot objectively say I've isolated the wheels' performance and say they run fast.

A zone 2 endurance ride on this bike yields the same times as a tempo ride on my commuter.

The 45mm profile and (presumably) sinusoidal pattern make cross-wind impact no worse than a typical box section profile.

I've, so far, had zero issues with them, but I've only put 250km on them
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Charltonfan1 on October 02, 2021, 01:07:22 AM
Ok thank you.

More general question - having previously lived in TO I couldn't imagine commuting via bike with the streetcars and poor drivers. You are brave!
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on October 04, 2021, 12:36:33 PM
Ok thank you.

More general question - having previously lived in TO I couldn't imagine commuting via bike with the streetcars and poor drivers. You are brave!

Haha Thanks!  You'd be surprised how many bike lanes have popped up in Toronto over the last few years.
That being said, I commute around Wilson Rd near Downsview, and if I need to do a long ride, I go out to Pickering/Durham
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on October 20, 2021, 09:26:18 AM
I've ordered a set of ent disc, hope my hubs will be loud as yours, I would love that

I am afraid the ENTs will be pretty quiet. 
I rode my old commuter the other day, which has silent Shimano hubs and I have come to realize:
When I am casually cycling to run some errands, I prefer silent
When I am doing a training session, or some sort of ride where I put in effort, I actually enjoy the noise:
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Irideslowly on November 03, 2021, 06:18:14 AM
I received the Elite Wheels wheelset.

I can confirm, the hub are obnoxiously loud.
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Charltonfan1 on November 03, 2021, 07:23:14 AM
I received the Elite Wheels wheelset.

I can confirm, the hub are obnoxiously loud.

Which one did you go for?

I'm waiting until 11.11 to order some BWS Rim brakes with DTSwiss 350 Hubs
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: Irideslowly on November 03, 2021, 08:34:29 AM
Their budget wheels. The Elite Wheels ENT
Title: Re: New Wheel Day - Elite Wheels BWT Disc
Post by: 1Sigma on November 03, 2021, 08:55:01 AM
I received the Elite Wheels wheelset.

I can confirm, the hub are obnoxiously loud.

@GilardiRT