Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Serge_K

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 82
1
Component Deals & Selection / Re: wheelset suggestions
« on: Today at 05:54:04 AM »
I've been defaulting to buying my wheels from Peter from Xiamen carbon speed, for reasons i've repeated 20x here already. You can chat him up on whatsapp and he can help you, including on the hub durability side of things.
Most of the chinese in house hubs are using DT swiss clones, afaik.
Dyneema spokes could be an interesting choice, because in principle, you could carry spare spokes bunched up at the bottom of your frame bag, and these wheels are very comfortable.
Your bike looks like a gravel bike? if you're going to use big tyres, hookless could make sense, because the sidewalls of the rim are supposed to be tougher on a hookless rim (pretty much the only advantage of hookless), so if you run straight into a boulder, hookless rims are less likely to break.

2
Yep, they're bo longer in "affordable" territory.

I'm French, so I grew up with Decathlon. I haven't looked at it closely, but my general understanding is 2 fold.
1. the bikes have been so popular they've been flying off the shelves, which an economist would argue means the price was too low (equilibrium pricing theory).
2. the bike is ridden by a pro team, and the team genuinely aims to perform at the highest level, so you'd expect the frame to be able to support this ambition, so they probably do spend a lot on materials and R&D. The French are often good at actual work, and even innovation, but really bad at marketing it. For example, recent interviews point to the attention they paid to frame stiffness during a sprint. Given the insane speeds at which sprints are won, and that there are countless stages where a sprint is won by less than a bike length, as sprinter will want a bike that will be very fast, and very stiff. This new frame solves for that.

So, it annoys me a lot that their bikes are now so expensive, and I would bet that this also annoys a lot of Decathlon employees & their friends, but it's also understandable. The competition is simply over pricing stuff across the board.

Given how tight a ship Decathlon has been running for decades, i'd bet their R&D costs are a fraction of the likes of Specialized, so I would bet that they could sell the frames at a much, much lower price point. But then, point #1, where the frames would just sell out all the time, and i would even expect a grey market with people selling frames they just bought in the secondary at a premium, precisely in an effort to find an equilibrium price. Because that's exactly what i'd do. If the prices were a no brainer, I'd buy frames and sell them to people abroad.

3
i dont think anybody has formally made such test, where you'd isolate the variable of wheel X in setup 1 uses T700, and wheel Y in the same exact setup, except it uses T1100. Because it'd be very hard to source the same rims and build the same wheels, and just change that variable. You'd also have to trust the factory is indeed providing the mix they claim they provide, as you can't validate it yourself, afaik.

The main reason why higher grades are used in rims is for weight, but T1100 is high modulus, so very stiff, but also very brittle. And a wheel needs to be impact resistant, so a 100% T1100 wheel doesnt exist, for example, it's going to be a mix. T700, and when it's used, T800, are the backbones of carbon stuff in bikes. T1000 / T1100 can be added to the mix, in proportions that factories do not like to disclose, to save on weight. You'd expect the wheel to be stiffer if T800 is used over T700, and T1100 over T800.

The new kids on the block are M40/M60, or T40/T60 (i think it's the same thing), and i understand they're fancier versions of T700 & T800. We've been seeing it in OEM frames for a couple of years, probably longer in branded ones (i think the likes of Sworks, Factor, Pinarello, not the maintstream ones), but I havent seen it in wheels.

And so, yes, T1100 should be less compliant, because of it's physical properties, as it'd be replacing T700 / T800 in the mix used.

4
Road Bike Frames, Wheels & Components / Re: Winspace T1550
« on: March 30, 2025, 02:51:01 PM »
Where did you find the carbon layup of the Van Rysel. What is T40, T60 compared to 1100, 1000... ?

One of the van rysel guys mentioned that during an interview i saw on youtube. GCN one, from memory.
40/60 i think is T or M. So i think T40 is M40 or 40M. It's all quite confusing and few people really know the ins and outs of the topic, i think - and certainly not me. T in T800 is for Toray. I think the M is for Mitsubishi. But i think Mitsubishi is making Toray fibers. I understand 40T and 30T is similar to T800 and T700. But more expensive and better performance. So 60T is probably like T1000.
Anyhow, it's apparently what expensive frames are made of (the high end stuff, like Factor, Sworks, Pinarello). Giant, Merida, Cube, Orbea, all these, afaik, use lower grade stuff, probably very similar to what our OEM frames have.
Also, does any of this really matter, or is it a flex? idk. But it's probably the tricks pulled to shave the last 50 or 100g off a frame, and it's probably why you have a jump in price, because T700 & T800 is everywhere, but T/M40/60 isn't.




5
I have a "winspace authorized dealer" bikeshop in my town and they said they warranty winspace frames/hyper wheels and they said winspace is great about covering repairs under warrenty on their wheels (theyve never seen a frame come in for repair) so that is reassuring

I believe that the crowd on this forum that builds their own bikes pays more attention to the inside of frames than most bike shops, because it's not in the interest of bike shops to raise hell with frame manufacturers / brands. In fact it's the opposite. As long as they feel the frame is still safe to ride, their interest is shipping the bike out of the door, hoping it doesn't collapse on itself. If it does collapse on itself, they still aren't liable, the bike manufacturer is.
If bike shops were behaving like Madpec on YT (or how Madpec is advertising themselves to be on YT, to apply extra cynicism), they would 1. sell fewer bikes 2. scare customers 3. annoy brands 4. potentially to achieve nothing but the satisfaction of having a flawless frame internally.

One reason i believe that is Cannondale. The whole silicone grease for bottom bracket rabbit hole i fell into to fix a creaky BB was basically invented by Cannondale, because their BBs used to be absolute dog $hit, and i can confirm, i have a supersix evo hi mid from the Peter Sagan era. Another reason is Peak Torque and his analysis of shimano plastic BB shells for PF BBs, as opposed to metal ones, because plastic allows for much shittier tolerances than metal. And him having to ream the BB on his Tavelo frame because otherwise he'd have cracked the frame, while we heard bike shops being like "nah that's fine, we just pushed the plastic cup hard in there".

So that's quite ironic: on here, I feel we're holding OEMs to a higher standard than western brands. I think that's great for competition & incentivizing OEMs to step up their game, and rewarding those who deserve our money, and penalizing those that try to sell crap / gaslight (workswell and winspace come to mind as recent examples, light carbon with the 17D, but also sellers of fakes, airwolf).

6
Road Bike Frames, Wheels & Components / Re: VeloBuild VB-TT-023
« on: March 29, 2025, 05:02:11 AM »
I've received a PM about the toolbox I have designed 3d printed for the VB-TT-023. If anyone wants the .stl file to print it yourself, feel free to download in on thingiverse:

https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:6988838

I suggest using PETG for this box, as it offers flexibility aswell as heat stability and UV resistance. Both pieces can be printed without support if you flip them to the flat side in your slicer. You'll need two M5 screws to attach it to the frame. Sadly using this toolbox, you will not be able to mount bottlecages in the frame correctly any more. I haven't found a way yet to circumvent this, but if I do I'll post a new revision.

Awesome!
Cautionary tale. 3d printed stuff tends to fail catastrophically in ways injected molded plastic doesnt. I had a 3d printed box behind my seat post on my propel, it worked until it just exploded. So, people, when you use 3d printed parts, be mindful of print orientation / layer lines, material fatigue, stress points, how to reinforce a print with non 3d printed parts like inserts, mesh and so on. Don't be like me, basically. Especially those who just DL free STLs from Thingiverse and send them to print without giving it much thought.

7
Yes I ride a lot with yearsly also 400.000m elevation and rac(ed) a lot with a usually around 20h of training per week. Thus I know my Tarmac SL7 very very well. I was also a bit sceptical about the chinese frames. But recently I bought a Carbonda 505 SL as gravel/road bike and i am amazed of how well it rides also compared to my SL7. Thus for only 700 dollars I will give the Seraph a try. I will even stick the same components on it, same wheels, same groupset (found a ultegra 11 speed di2 for cheap from a local Conti riders old second bike), same saddle and most importantly i have also on my SL7 the Roval Rapide cockpit, so I can compare that. I will try to report here.

Still wondering if the 140mm front brake disc will work though.

My good man, please make a dedicated thread here to share your thoughts when you're done. You could break the internet. Genuinely, if you transfer the components, including wheels, tyres, cockpit, given how much you ride, your FTP, the type of riding you do, you comparing a real SL7 to this frame will credibly answer questions almost every one looking at chinese frames is asking. I would even want you on the nero show podcast shooting $hit w Jesse Coyle, because again, you'd be credible.

It's exciting :D

8
Road Bike Frames, Wheels & Components / Re: Winspace T1550
« on: March 29, 2025, 04:40:06 AM »
I'm not an expert, but i've bought a dozen OEM frames in the last 3y, and if i had to pay Winspace prices to receive that, i'd go ape shit.
Loose carbon strands in critical areas (headset & bottom bracket cups) isn't exactly reassuring. carbon fiber strands without the resin matrix have zero strength. So if the edges of the frame like that has such strands, critical areas of the frame potentially have compromised strength.
Now, that being said, you have a T47 BB, which kind of exists to allow shoddy manufacturing, which is exactly what you have here. As long as the metal shell is bonded to the frame, having loose strands around it scares me much less than if the BB were press fit. The headset bearing cups dont look pretty, but unless there's a clear oval (vs round) or a clear lip that's not of constant thickness and so on, i think you're safe.
The ugly patch in the middle of the BB area looks bad, but it doesnt look like you have big ass shards that weren't compressed like the frame we saw last week another user post. It's probably from manufacturing process, and just shows they suck.

Basically, if you look at the inside of the fake Ostro frames on this forum, and at these 2 winspace frames, i know who i'd work with... The level of irony in the fact sellers of fake products have products that look 10x tighter than Winspace...

Patlean mentioned that winspace may be struggling financially from supporting a racing team and being burdened with out of date wheels. that would make sense, and i would expect them to cut corners.

I'd stay away from that brand, because you pay a LOT more than what competitors offer (all over this forum), but they treat you like a$$ if you complain. And they have the audacity to say this is normal to receive such frames at the price point, so why take that trade? For anyone wanting to spend winspace territory money, i'd consider at the fake Factors on the thread here, and get it without a logo. Or get Peter's upcoming Gran Turismo frame, because it's likely going to be a similar price point with T1100, 40T, 30T fibers. The new van rysel aero frame uses T1100, T40 and T60, similar to the real Factor frames, so we're talking high end stuff. Much higher end than Winspace, btw.


9
Road Bike Frames, Wheels & Components / the new Van Rysel RCR-F
« on: March 28, 2025, 04:10:11 PM »
The new Van Rysel RCR-F just dropped on youtube. Very exciting. Will be curious to hear how it compares with the Cervelo S5 & the likes in a wind tunnel. Looks super aero, deep tubes everywhere, especially the front end (deep fork, deep & narrow head tube). It makes the canyon aeroad look dated (which it is, as this one doesn't use the updated UCI rules on tube shapes).

What choices do we have in chinese frames, when it comes to aero frames? Anything that looks like the Van Rysel RCR-F?

I love my 268 from Long Teng, which looks a lot like the old ostro.
lots of people riding fake Ostros, and they do look awesome, and the ostro tested fast in the wind tunnel.

What else?

10
I can compare it at least to my SL7 on which I have 120.000 km :D

Btw so can someone confirm me that it is compatible with front 140 mm disc rotors?

Will be very curious to hear your thoughts on how the 2 frames compare, given you're pushing equipment in ways that 90+% of the users on this forum dont.

11
I stopped using the foam things, because i never felt or heard the difference, btw. Which confuses me. I actually try to keep slack hose inside the frame to make disassembly easier, so i dont think my hoses are so tight inside that they can't move.
Maybe i'm just lucky.
Maybe if you dont use the foam, you'd have to be unlucky to hear a rattle?
If you route 4 hoses, dont use foam, it will make you want to end yourself. Dont ask me how i know.

It's funny that our experiences differ like that.

12
Component Deals & Selection / Re: Juin Disc Brakes
« on: March 28, 2025, 08:34:02 AM »
Does anyone know where you can get Juin components from (as close to source as possible?)

If you are looking to buy several sets, probably at least 5, then you'll find cheaper prices on Alibaba easily, but then you have to figure out shipping, and Aliexpress has incredibly cheap shipping (a lot of what you pay on aliexpress is shipping, when they say free shipping, you're obviously paying for it in the price).
If you just need one set, realize that they don't need your business, so even if you talk to an employee there, you're not magically going to get a great deal. In fact you're likely going to pay more, because aliexpress resellers get wholesale prices themselves.

One good thing on Alix that you dont have on bang good, for eg, is competition. bang good sells one product from one seller, and therefore prices tend to be high. Alix is a free for all, including scammers, so there's much more competition, driving prices down. Jack Ma created the whole thing literally to create a tool to allow anyone to sell anything.

13
For me winspace is a chinese brand that executed well on the western influencer strategy. By that i mean they sell bikes at a premium because of the branding and all that marketing. Which means that value wise, you should be able to pay less for a frame without the branding and marketing budget.
Basically, Winspace is some chinese low end version of why Specialized or Trek are so expensive.

And that's fine, it's just not for me. I automatically distrust reviews from people who directly benefit from hyping up the product, it's the most basic form of conflict of interest. Which again, it's fine, some will argue the American ethos of something like "you need marketing to sell something otherwise it wont sell". I'm French, i value craftsmanship, artisans, and so on. I think that if your work speaks for itself, you'll find work, and work will find you. But obviously, that doesnt scale, and now even Time changed hands and is now American. Let's say i'm a dinosaur.

That said, recently there was this: https://chinertown.com/index.php/topic,5729

When you charge premium, the social contract, if not formal contract, is that you stand behind your product. And apparently, they behave worse than the OEMs I deal with.

Most of the feedback you'll find from Workswell here is negative, ironically. Maybe we should refer to them as Doesntworkswell.

If you feel that you could fairly casually and happily spend an extra 1500$ on a given bike, i'd say do that. Support your local bike shop and save yourself the time and mental load of the rabbit hole of chinese carbon.

14
would you buy a car based on how easy it is to open the trunk?
Such an odd way of choosing a tyre, given it's the only thing that connects you to the ground. Would you buy bad rubber over good rubber, all else equal, because it's (allegedly) easier to install?

15
Cyclocross Frames, Wheels & Components / Re: 9velo GV35 GV45
« on: March 28, 2025, 05:32:25 AM »
A lot of people in this forum (and others) love the GV45 wheelset from 9velo.

They do? I'm not saying people here hate these wheels, but i rarely see the brand mentioned, and when it is mentioned, people usually chime in to say it's nothing to write home about, as pointed out by Nkearb.
If you spend 15 minutes on this forum looking at threads in chronological order, you will see the same OEM names popping up over and over again. The last dozen wheels i've bought, i bought from Peter from Xiamen carbon speed, because value is there, specs are there, quality is there, and service is there. And i dont want logos. Peter is easy to deal with and transparent. Basically ticks all my boxes. You will find a lot of people here who prefer buying from Aliexpress though because they dont want to deal with emails and whatsapp conversations. In which case, Elite is probably the leader of aliX wheels.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 82