New 2026 Aero-light frame from Light Cycling

Started by BeR, August 04, 2026, 09:42:49 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

patliean1

TLDR - 5 seatposts later. Still the same slippage. My bike is still unridable.

I have been going back forth deciding whether or not to make this post. My original hope was that my issues would eventually get resolved privately and all would be well moving forward.

First I'd like to start by saying Daniel has been EXCELLENT in terms of communication every step of the way. It's not as he's in the factory literally manufacturing the frames himself. I am not in the business of publicly criticizing any company. Especially without giving a brand the opportunity to make things right. It makes me look bad even if my issues are legitimate. And I don't want the reputation of being a diva or a grifter like other more known engineering YouTubers.

My bike is unridable. And has been unridable since the day I built it.

Stage 1: The seatpost was missing with my original order. I was informed I could use a genuine SL8 which I just so happened to have a spare. The SL8 seat post slipped immediately. Added additional grip paste, metal shims, and additional torque. Still slipped. 6.2Nm, 8Nm, 10Nm

Stage 2: Light Cycling rush shipped me two seatposts. THANK YOU! - A 0mm and 15mm setback. Both of them slipped with the identical parameters above. Shims, grip paste, 6.2Nm, 8Nm, 10Nm

Stage 3: Rather than completely cancel the entire project at this point, I told Daniel I'm happy to just play the role of beta tester instead of YouTuber reviewer. However, I explained to him the conditions which causes my seat post to slip. I included photos and videos. I even included video of a genuine SL8 around the clamping area for further context.

Stage 4: Light Cycling solution was two more seat posts quickly delivered. This time with added grip paint applied around each seat post. And re-worked seat post clamp with a grip texture on the side of the clamp that interfaces directly with the post. Still slipped. 6.2Nm, 8Nm, 10Nm

Regarding the stress test video above: It only demonstrates static force applied downward. This is not why seat posts slip. They slip because a seat post flexes. Laterally and fore/aft. Because humans don't interact with their saddle/post from a single static angle. And these movements and vibrations of the seatpost creates stress which subsequently flexes at the clamping point. Which in this case is the seat post clamp itself.

Any small movement of the clamp itself (due to frame fitment tolerances) is an opportunity for the clamp itself to unload the forces required to keep the seat post in place. I've had this discussion with multiple industry people. All who explicitly agreed. Again...I've had the very same issue with the original TanTan X68 SL8 clone frame.

Where do we go from here? - After now 12 to 14 individual working days of my time troubleshooting with no positive progression, I can safely say my efforts with this build has come to an end for now. I will not be answering any future questions about performance, entertaining solutions, or offering my subjective opinion. No YouTube videos or media will be posted. Everything above has been documented directly with Daniel. I also suggested Daniel to make some sort of public statement about this issue over a month ago. Transparency offers more trust than it does harm. Would be nice for him to follow through with this considering paying customers are experiencing the problems. However he is fully within his right to dictate how he wants to conduct his business. Not really my business. Nor do I have any emotional feelings towards this experience.

@Eddy_Twerckx - Issues aside I initially thought the bike felt solid out on the road. Until I realized my ultra stiff wheels were doing the heavy lifting. Having this bike on the indoor trainer the past 3 days. It's the flexiest frame I've ridden in years.

Dark17

That's such a bummer, specially the flexiest frame. Maybe the other brands like tantan are the same.

Eddy_Twerckx

To expand a little on the flex. Having flex is not a bad thing in itself. It's a very comfortable bike. But you have to know what you're getting and what you want. Like I said in my earlier post, the bike rides very similar to my old Aethos. The Aethos is known to be fairly flexy and yet it's a very popular bike. So being flexy doesn't mean it's a bad bike and dissuade some people from buying it. The seatpost might but that's a separate issue. My issue with the flex is that I want a super stiff race bike that can handle 1600W sprints. And a stiff bike it is not. So it just doesn't suit my needs. If you want a comfortable bike that's fun to ride and has some aero qualities, it fits the bill. Or if you don't need the absolute stiffest bike. So my "review" is mostly just what type of bike I want.

todayfoccassia

Quote from: Eddy_Twerckx on <strong>Today</strong> at 11:38:00 AMTo expand a little on the flex. Having flex is not a bad thing in itself. It's a very comfortable bike. But you have to know what you're getting and what you want. Like I said in my earlier post, the bike rides very similar to my old Aethos. The Aethos is known to be fairly flexy and yet it's a very popular bike. So being flexy doesn't mean it's a bad bike and dissuade some people from buying it. The seatpost might but that's a separate issue. My issue with the flex is that I want a super stiff race bike that can handle 1600W sprints. And a stiff bike it is not. So it just doesn't suit my needs. If you want a comfortable bike that's fun to ride and has some aero qualities, it fits the bill. Or if you don't need the absolute stiffest bike. So my "review" is mostly just what type of bike I want.

are you also having seatpost slip issues? I have my fingers on the trigger to order, but if this isn't an isolated issue on Patrick's specific frame, I may keep looking elsewhere

Lebie89

Quote from: todayfoccassia on <strong>Today</strong> at 02:26:52 PMare you also having seatpost slip issues? I have my fingers on the trigger to order, but if this isn't an isolated issue on Patrick's specific frame, I may keep looking elsewhere

He is. If I was you I would wait a couple of weeks, as a few of us are in the process of getting frames delivered, and can post more feedback.

Honestly I am a bit disappointed due to the news from Patrick, but time will tell if we all have the same seatpost and flexibility issues.

@patliean1: Could you maybe share if the RF10 feels more flexy than the X68?

Eddy_Twerckx

Quote from: todayfoccassia on <strong>Today</strong> at 02:26:52 PMare you also having seatpost slip issues? I have my fingers on the trigger to order, but if this isn't an isolated issue on Patrick's specific frame, I may keep looking elsewhere

I was yes. The last two rides have been good though, no slippage. One ride outside, one ride inside. I was having tons of issues with third party seatposts made for Tarmacs. I've since gone back to the stock seatpost and loaded it up with carbon gripper paste. Like, a lot. Tightened to 9Nm. Holding for now.