See likes given/taken
| Post info | No. of Likes |
|---|---|
|
Re: 2022 Cervelo S5
Questioning one's spending choices on fake frames: BAD Insulting one's spending choices on legitimate (albeit expensive) frames: GOOD Chinatown logic... April 02, 2023, 08:49:25 PM |
1 |
Re: Thinking of Going Deeper – A More Honest Look Inside the Replica Frame Industry
Ironically, I think the effect of this thread has only been to increase interest in counterfeit frames. I’d actually disagree — the interest in counterfeit frames has always been there, it’s just that people are now more openly talking about it. I understand it’s a sensitive and divisive topic. Some will agree, others won’t, and yes — it’s technically illegal. I’m not denying that. Is it in the true spirit of the forum? Maybe not entirely. But the reality is that the demand is huge, whether we like it or not. And with demand comes discussion. That’s the value of threads like this — they spark conversation, debate, and hopefully, awareness. I’m not here to promote counterfeits, but if people are going to explore that route anyway, I’d rather they be informed and aware of the risks — safety being a big one. It’s a bit of a catch-22. You either bury your head in the sand and pretend it’s not happening, or you engage with it in a way that helps people make smarter decisions. June 20, 2025, 01:29:34 AM |
1 |
Re: Thinking of Going Deeper – A More Honest Look Inside the Replica Frame Industry
The replica fork in practice generally isn't lighter than an actual sl8 fork. The quoted weight may be, but there's a very wide tolerance quoted. There is one report of failure that I'm aware of . I did a fair amount of bike law in a prior life and I can vouch that carbon parts from big companies fail too. In fairness, they are subject to remedies that tantan and others likely aren't, but hey, if you're injured I'm not sure that's a major factor. That said, yes, I suspect that the factory producing for Specialized in all likelihood has more qc oversight than the average "replica" as most are sold by resellers. As far as parts fitment goes, there is a very slight variance between the actual sl8 post and the tantan post. Reports have been of 1mm or so. Likely a cad or scanning error. Otherwise the parts work. But to your greater point, I don't think anyone buying these frames expect them to be "as good" or "better". I've said before that I bought one because I'm old af and wasn't sure I could make an sl8 actually usable for me, and risking $700 was much different than risking 3k+. Turns out the bike fits, and is a very nice ride, nice enough that I grab it almost always before some high end og bikes. I honestly don't feel the need to upgrade to a "real" sl8 at this point for the marginal gain. I don't doubt that the real bike is "better" in some way, but I would speculate that a) its not 5x better and b) that confirmation bias aside, without labels you'd be hard pressed to tell. I get that at the end of the day folks have an issue with flat out fakes and "homage" things. Bicycles, watches, handbags, whatever. I don't begrudge that. I'm living on an adequate but "fixed" income now and can't play in the luxury world any longer. But if the "real" value of something is grossly inflated by marketing costs, distribution costs, dealer networks yada, I'm ok with not paying that tax. Thanks for your participation here, your bikes and photos are well composed and beautiful. June 20, 2025, 06:56:36 AM |
1 |
|
Re: Thinking of Going Deeper – A More Honest Look Inside the Replica Frame Industry
I am ideologically opposed to counterfeits and believe frames like the X68 risk being deemed counterfeits, even when not branded. However, I do like this thought experiment, and even the information so far is going a long way towards dispelling the rumors that these are simply frames that fell off of a truck. At a high level, we need to remember that the load of a modern carbon frame is carried through its external structure, which is why it is referred to as a monocoque frame. Regardless of the construction method, if you can build a frame that passes ISO testing, it's likely to feel remarkably similar; the shape of that structure will be the most significant factor in determining the stiffness of the frame. Details like layup and wall thickness can make a difference, but they are an order of magnitude less important. That said, the most significant issues with counterfeits of high-end frames are that I don't get the sense that the people doing the replication understand where the original designers made tradeoffs to achieve the performance of their frames. Remember a lot of these frames have known drawbacks like the lack of front-end stiffness of the SSE, front-end performance and reliability on Factors, and seat tube / seat post clamp + stay cracking issues on the Dogma F12 and F. Given that the outside form has a significant influence on the structure of the frame, its not a surprise that replicas seem to suffer from the same issues, potentially at a higher rate. I think VB even stopped making their Dogma clone. My questions to a replica builder would be to understand if they identified any potential weaknesses in the original design and how they managed that. I am guessing they don't think about it at all as they are focused on the form, and it's better to buy an original open mold where some engineer thought about and made decisions, conscious of the tradeoffs they were introducing. To me, an analogy is that the replica is having a Frank Lloyd Wright replica house built op top of a waterfall with the help of an architect, but without a review by a structural engineer. The open mold is a structurally sound McMansion with little architectural involvement. June 20, 2025, 01:31:56 PM |
1 |
Re: Thinking of Going Deeper – A More Honest Look Inside the Replica Frame Industry
with respect to the quality of the production we heard the same thing about carbon wheels direct from China for years. as it stands today, i don't for see myself ever buying a traditional western brand wheel ever again. the pace of advancement in wheels from China is way out ahead of the pack. Whoa there. Please don't take what I said out of context. I am talking about replica brands NOT Chinese production or Chinese brands. IMO, there are people in China as qualified as any western engineer to design a bike frame. I also have huge respect for the wheel brands that are bringing lightweight layups and focusing on what they do well to deliver excellent products. I also have experience working with Chinese factories on projects, and though language barrier can make communications awkward, they are in no way worse than Western factories. Trade war be damned I have nothing but respect for smart, honest businesses trying to make a buck. June 20, 2025, 06:10:27 PM |
1 |
Re: Thinking of Going Deeper Counterfeit Frames – UPDATE and Fund Link
If your project succeeds, I will be happy to contribute to the cause (even if the frame in question does not directly concern me)....I am waiting for the counter to reach at least £300 GBP Thanks Bonus79! The counter is at £179.19! Someone I know not on the Forum has ordered and X68 so he said he is happy to pass me his frame for inspection I am contacting this company this week https://carboncyclesolutions.co.uk/ June 25, 2025, 05:08:37 AM |
1 |
|
LTK266-D-SL, race frame, 680g, <800g w/paint & metal parts (M), fits 35mm+ tires
I don't think there is a thread for this frame yet. I spotted it earlier today, and while conservative in terms of design, it ticks a lot of boxes for someone looking for a frame that can handle a bit of cross, light gravel, and road riding. Things I like:
https://www.ltbikes.com/index/products/view/id/421.html EDIT: Now that these bikes are out in the wild, I have added comments in red EDIT2: Adding content to this post to reflect some build hints and purchase configurations. Things to consider when ordering this frame:
"Official" build from @Eddy-haideli. Size S ![]() @bedampft DuraAce Di2, "Mixtape" vinyl wrap, and Giant Contact SLR Bar + Stem. Size L ![]() @sakizashi SRAM 1x Rival E1/D1 mix all-road build w/ kalloy uno stem and Hope RX2 calipers. Size M ![]() @klrdd Sram Force E1 AXS roadbuild w/Tavelo barstem. Size L ![]() @BeeMC Lightweight Sram mix w/ XMCS barstem. Size S ![]() @TidyDinosaur Flyweight sub-6.2kg build with Avian barstem. Size S ![]() u/sundayvacation from r/chinesecarbon. AXS mix, LB Aria wheelset, Tavelo barstem, Pantone Warm Grey 8C paint. Size M ![]() @Halfshark Di2 build w/ riser barstem. Size M ![]() @MARIOVL Permeants St-09 Di2 build. Size S ![]() @alexgaignard Di2 build with LTK barstem and AeroRaptor Wheels. Size M ![]() @OGLuka, Di2, Magene TEO carbon crankset, Light Carbon HBR17 barstem. Size XL
June 29, 2025, 12:36:26 AM |
1 |
|
Re: CT Scan Project: Real Frame vs Replica – Next Step
I think he‘s trying to say that you’ve made your point many times now across different threads. And I too fail to see why we need yet another one. Some might find your endeavour interesting enough to support you. Others don’t. I personally think that scanning one or two frames from one source and comparing it with the original might be of interest for owners of that particular frame. But I don’t think it brings much value to anyone else beyond that. We can’t draw any general conclusions from it. Arguably, it might not even give us any information about the general quality of TanTan frames because everything we know indicates that they’re sourcing it from elsewhere. I think it is what it is: You buy a replica of unknown origin means you take a risk.That’s not really gonna change no matter how many frames we’re scanning. June 29, 2025, 10:10:39 AM |
1 |
|
Re: Zen Carbon Wheelset Build – 40/45 with Carbon Spokes, H-Works HX Hubs, Sub-1kg
I spoke with Zara from Zen—she may be posting on the forum soon. But for anyone interested in the meantime, here’s some useful information: • ✅ Rim specifications, including rider weight limits and individual rim weights • ✅ Carbon spoke weights • ✅ Example pricing for a 50/60 mm wheelset These wheels are built with the H-Works SR270 rear hub https://h-works.cn/products/hw-261-rear 3.95 mm or 5 mm carbon spokes, offering a high-performance, lightweight setup ideal for road disc builds. Price varies obviously depending on rim carbon type Shipping is offered with taxes but you will need to contact for prices for your own country! https://www.instagram.com/zencarbonbike?igsh=bGtvdDcxdzVxMzA0 https://zencarbonbike.com info@zencarbonbike.com +86 15160726618 +86 13218277787 June 30, 2025, 03:43:54 PM |
1 |
Re: Zen Carbon Wheelset Build – 40/45 with Carbon Spokes, H-Works HX Hubs, Sub-1kg
Order placed, cheers for all the hard work on these Sander! Hey Justin No worries always happy to help fellow forum members
July 01, 2025, 12:24:17 AM |
1 |