Some more testing done, a bit more due, but here's my impressions so far
HardwareLook & Feel is fairly cheap, but sturdy. A lot of plastic, and comes with very limited accessories (stem/rubber band mount and a security cord, so no cable/case/screen protection). Depending on the mount used it seems somewhat prone to no/limited stoppage at a quarter turn as well, but it hasn't come loose yet.
vs. C706: Charging port is easier to open and seems slightly more trustworthy regarding water ingress. The bell is slightly louder and more distinct ("ding ding ding ding" vs "Rrrrring Rrrrring" 😅) than Magene's one. C706 comes with more accessories and feels a bit more premium in general. Size is about the same.
ScreenSomewhat prone to glare but so far I haven't had trouble reading it at all. Auto brightness works well too, and the touch screen feels responsive enough. You can set up a screen flash on navigation prompts but I haven't found it all that useful.
vs. C706: the BSC500 comes with a touch screen lock which might be handy in rainy conditions, glare is worse on the C706 but no massive issue either.
GPS and data qualityPerfect - that said, it's using dual band GPS by default, so you'd expect that. Haven't tried single band or its automatic mode yet. File exports (.fit) look decent and import into intervals.icu fine.
vs. C706: Very similar deal really, no notes.
Maps and RoutingI haven't managed to get road names to show up in navigation prompts, but other than that the routing has been pretty great. The track's visuals could be better (or adjustable) but maybe that'll come later (I think it's a thing on the BiNavi Air?). I've used GPX and Komoot imports thus far and both worked fine - similarly to the C706, you first add the route to the app before transferring it over to the device.
Navigation prompts can be displayed on all pages (overlay) or included as a data field. Alongside the prompt sound and/or voice instructions (either on the device or your phone), it's hard to miss a turn. If you still do, rerouting works but is a bit slow to calculate the new route initially.
Maps are mostly preloaded - and thankfully so, because there is no user frontend to update them. Instead, you have to download new versions from the website, connect the device to a PC (only works at full battery it seems) and transfer the files over. The USB transfer speeds are
abysmal - like half an hour for about 1GB of data. Some countries seem to be missing from the initial setup but are available on the website, e.g. Austria.
it does have some quirks regarding the GPS track rendering: For example, rerouting looks like it's overshooting the re-join point, but then disappears when you're back on route. Tracks are simplified (less geo points/more straight lines) in certain scenarios - this happened both when selecting/viewing a route and when coming back past a bit that I had already ridden in the same sessions (did two laps of the same track, basically). It doesn't happen with the active track once you are navigating though, so it's far from a big issue in my opinion.
vs. C706: Slightly better map rendering on the BSC500 in my opinion (street names are fewer, don't interfere as much and can be disabled), better initial map package but more cumbersome with updates.
ClimbingIt comes with iClimb 2.0 which means it only starts the climbing mode while routing a track - which is completely fine with me, but if you are looking for "free ride iClimb", you might have to keep your fingers crossed for an update, or look at the BiNavi Air or the Magene.
It also seems like it's pulling the climb data from the route file, which feels superior and more accurate to whatever database Magene is using. I have only done some very mild local climbs though, so maybe more on that after the weekend as I'm planning do to a bit more then.
vs. C706: Better accuracy on the BSC500 (depending on your GPX source of course), but no free ride climbing mode.
BatteryBattery usage has been swinging around 5-7% per hour with 2 connected sensors, making it trend towards the lower end of their claims. I'll probably end up using this in an ultra in three weeks time, so we'll have some proper data then 😅
vs. C706: Similar capacity, similar usage and estimated life.
Data FieldsPlenty of customization, if a bit cumbersome as pointed out by Stormy - there's a limited number of layouts, and they are also limited to certain pages, all of which feels like a bit of an odd choice. But with some trial and error you should be able to get a decent layout for your needs going. The zone graph fields are
really nice.
Unfortunately, there's no 5min/20min average field for power or HR data.
vs. C706: More/full layout flexibility on the Magene, but similar choice of fields overall (and similar missing fields). The device has to be connected to make changes while the Magene's screens can be edited "offline" too.
Ecosystem and account dataiGPSport seemingly wants to have a bit of a "Strava at home", leading to some noteworthy stuff IMHO.
During account setup, you are asked for your city/region of residence as they have a local leaderboard thing going. You can't opt out of providing this info, but at least only activities set to "public" are counted towards the stats so you can stay "invisible/inactive".
A bit more of an issue in my book is the fact that if you connect your komoot account and then import a planned route, it's automatically set to public and thus added to the public library of routes. You can not change this in the app at all (you can via the
web interface but that's super basic and most users won't even know about it I reckon), so if you don't want that you'll have to export the GPX from komoot and then import it as that gives you the option to have it stay private. I assume it'll be similar for Strava.
If you want to share a picture with some ride stats after your workout, you'll have to set it to public as well as sharing is completely disabled otherwise, even if "sharing" in that case would only be image generation 🙄
vs. C706: No similar functionality (and thus issues) on Magene's side.
Overall, I think the BSC500 is better value for money if you can look past the basic look & feel, don't need/want a freeride climb mode and either don't care about map updates (or Austria 😬) or the hassle they come with.
Magene's C706 feels more premium and while it's still a bit rough around the edges as well, it feels like a more streamlined experience in total.
If anyone has specific questions, particularly regarding the comparison to the Magene, let me know