Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - tssy5

Pages: [1] 2
1
Road Bike Frames, Wheels & Components / Re: Please recommend a frame
« on: September 06, 2024, 12:43:53 AM »
Just like Macedingle said, Winspace T1500 / T1550 is probably what you are looking for, slightly above budget but it checks most of your boxes: aero, stiff, disc, takes mechanical groupset.

I had a chance to try it from one of my local club riders, the geometry is very aggressive that I think I would only recommend to those who races / considered themselves flexible.

However the official website says max tyre clearance is 28mm, not sure if that's a deal breaker for you.

2
1054g
thru axle 35g, 1019g.
derailleur hanger 20g (?), 1000g.
White paint... 75g (?), 925g
4 cage bolts, 10g (?), 915g
Size 54 advertised as 865g, that's a 50g difference, or 6% deviation. I guess anything in the 5% range is to be expected. Better safe than sorry.

6500RMB = 815 EUR + 60$ shipping, this is pricey indeed.
The Factor box makes you wonder... would that be in instance of special access to the factory floor?

I just wish the logo said Tractor and not Factor, but this is a pretty bike indeed. Having a frame from a Factor factory but with Tractor logo would be peak troll.

It is the T1000 one so it would be more expensive, mine is T800 so it is around 450 EUR without shipping, probably I should get a T1000 for my next frame to see if it is going to be stiffer.

3
wow it looks sick! able to advice where did you get this frame?

You just need to search "Ostro VAM" in aliexpress.

4
I thought that everyone selling bike parts has to adhere to the ISO4210 testing protocol anyway as it is obligatory in most countries. Maybe someone with more background knowledge in the world of engineering and standards can explain better.

But what that means is that fatigue testing of sample frames doesn’t really set Chinese frames apart from the big brands. It is the level of QC (or its existence in the first place) that makes the difference. Right? What good is fatigue testing of one sample frame if they then crank out thousands of these frames without ever looking at any of them before they get shipped?

Maybe I could share some more on this topic.

For a bike manufacturer, no matter legit or fake, they got all sort of QC failed frames, but those that really are unsafe to ride, usually will be disposed and will not be sold, simply because it could lead to fatal accident, no one wants to risk that, even for a factory that makes replica.

Then, this part people probably would be more familar, the rest of the products would go into different class, Class A, B, C etc.

A could be the best product, such as perfect paint, alignments etc..
B could be less than ideal, some minor issues.
C could be merely acceptable, maybe some alignments are off, but still won't give you too much trouble building that bike and you could still ride safely.

Here's the thing, those you bought from legit brands, most of the time they are Class A (please note "most of the time"), you are paying big money for the best products after all.
Then where did those from Class B & C go? No way in hell they are disposing them because there are a lot of money involved in making them, they might be secertly sold to different retailers, usually to those not so well-known retailers, or they might just sell them themselves, get a promotion going and sell them with a discounted price.

There are a lot of retailers out there, some constantly bought Class B product and sell as cheap frames, some bought Class C and sell even cheaper, that's just how it works. Some evil retailers exist, they might somehow got their hands on those disposed failed frames, and sell them with a dirt cheap price. That's the reason why I would stay away from those $200 USD carbon frames. It is difficult for a factory to get away if the frame eventually breaks, but a lot easier for a retailer.

5
It's fantastic that they are safety testing at the facility you visited. It's surprising to me because a lot of the retailers for these frames change often, though I guess there are a few that have been around a while. Is their testing data verified with an authority like SGS? Can you get their certificates?

If you live where these replicas and counterfeits are illegal, reselling them with a disclaimer is also unlawful. Expecting that not to harm anyone down the line is some "laws don't apply to me" bullshit. These laws exist because disclaimers aren't enough, so it's still your problem and reflects on you. If you said, "I keep these and ride them into the ground," it would be more of a "meh." If people are brazen enough to try and sell counterfeits to a company like Pros Closet, you should be able to see how just contributing to putting fakes out there hurts other cyclists who just want a great deal and aren't getting the bike they thought they were. (https://www.theproscloset.com/blogs/news/how-to-catch-a-counterfeit-cervelo-rca)

I don't have their certificates, nor found any lying around when visiting their factory. To be honest, even if they did present me one, it could also be forged right? I looked at their testing equipment and saw some frames getting tested, I think that's enough for me.

About the reselling thing, let's just say there are a lot of luxury items such as watches and handbags being listed, some claimed they are replica, if that's illegal, I dunno, it has been like that for more than a decade, at least I never tricked anyone thinking the replica I sold are real, those who bought my replica are usually DIY person tho.

6
This is not intended to be mean or judgemental, so I hope we can take this response in the sprit of open discussion.

RE #1: Anecdata like this isn't helpful, and to me, the bigger question is whether or not the factory is even testing these frames for safety and failure. If you work with a reputable Chinese factory, they generate a surprising amount of data via testing in rigs to understand fatigue and lower the odds of a frame-breaking. Is the result a guarantee that a product won't break? No. But it does mean that the failure modes are known, and the probability of a frame-breaking meets the ISO standards. Not collecting the data means that it wasn't considered. This is similar to the arguments for and against helmets. Using a helmet provides a data-backed way to mitigate the consequences of an event. Still, there is no direct way to measure the risk faced on an individual ride if you choose not to wear a helmet and you can convince yourself that other factors might make it safer to not wear one.

RE #2: Nearly any race bike frame equipped with similar modern components will be 90% as good as a WT level super bike. Use electronic shifting, use similar wheels and tires, match the contact points and I think its near impossible to find a 10% difference in overall peformance.

I've had the pleasure of riding an Emonda ALR and a Gen 8 Madone now. Even as a smaller rider where the frame matters more as a percentage of aero or weight or whatever, there was no way to look at my ride data and tell the difference between the alloy not aero bike and the WT race bike. You take that from 20-22mph to like 28mph, and yes, there is now a measurable difference, but it's not even 5% and still within the error of my ability to test things on a loop.

How much time and money are you spending trying to make your replica work? How much cheaper does it really end up than something like the Emonda ALR?

Does the extra clout gained from a fake replica do anything for you? I don't think anyone on any group ride will care about this, and if they do, honestly, they are jerks.

If you are saying that a replica bike does no harm because you wouldn't be buying the real thing anyway, what do you do when you move on from the frame? Just throw it away? I suspect that the fakes I have seen being passed off as the real thing often started their life with the first reseller saying, "hey this isnt a real Pinarello" (or other brand), and the second reseller either forgot or isn't enough of a bike person to realize that other people can tell the difference on inspection.

Edit: I want to clarify that I think troll bikes are hilarious—like the LTK bike badged as a "Tractor," for example—but these aren't replicas or counterfeit bikes.

Don't worry about it, any sensible human being would be skeptical towards replicas / Chinese brands given their history of selling cheap low quality junks to the world. I was just like you a few years back.

1. About safety for the replica frame, maybe I can give some "insider" info, a year ago I got a chance to visit a replica factory in Dongguan, they got all sort of equipments for the stress/failure/drop test, the replica frames are going through a series of safety tests before final inspection. The equipment they are using to test don't look like state of the art, but it does it's job. I guess those are second-hand testing equipments from legit brands, not sure, but imo, I have seen the process and equipment for testing the replica, and I believe I can trust them to be at least safe to ride. Funny thing is that factory also help manufacture frames for some "legit Chinese brand", so yeah, it is just that shady, you never know, but I can't talk too much for this part, let's just say a lot of people ride their products now.


2. Well yes, there isn't much difference for an alloy road bike to a carbon road bike, but about the clout, not everyone goes with replica aiming just to pretend rich or something, for what purpose they bought replica for, that's their business, I am just here to share what I know about these Chinese frames. Personally, I like to try different frames and do a little bit research on them, sometimes I ride my TCR, sometimes I ride my replica, sometimes I borrow and ride my friend's high-end bike, that's the fun part for me as a roadie.

About the replica I don't need, I would just sell them online listed as replica from aliexpress, I don't want or need to trick the others, it is not the money I need, I need the space, my home doesn't have the space for too many frames. If anyone sells a replica and lsited as the real thing, that has something to do with that person rather than the replica itself.

7
I'm beginning to see Chinese bike frames and components more as a tuner market for bike builds. Anyone can walk into a boutique bike shop and buy $6-10k + USD bike, but where's the fun in that? Now you have this expensive bike that you have to baby, think about resale and only get serviced for more $$$ at the same bike shop, while gaining zero knowledge in actual bike maintenance. There's something fun about an open mold bike because you built it, know it's strengths/weaknesses and you can ride the bike hard without too much monetary repercussions. There's also the bigger satisfaction of gapping/dropping cyclists on the bling bikes. The money save can be used for more training, better nutrition, date night with the gf/missus, etc.

Well said! I am into trying different bikes and their geometry, testing the ride and stuff, it has been a real fun, there's no way I am going to pay $5k USD for each of them...

8
Looks also pretty cool to me! It's awesome that you went for this matte stealthy black. Bought as well some original parts like the head spacer ring, and seatpost wedge. I'm also still doubting if I add under the headset top cover a rubber ring to prevent getting moisture in the headset bearings.

For my build:
I still need a chain, cassette, and wheels. Received this week the chainring 1x, which is a Rotor Qarbon Q-ring with 52t but I received the 50t so I need to wait for that too.

That's a cool chainring. The little parts like headset spacers and top cover came with the frame so I don't need to buy them again, however the bolts they provided are pretty low quality so I bought some titanium bolts and replaced them.

9
I own several replicas and real branded bikes, also have borrowed from friends and ridden the real thing that my replica is trying to copy. My experience is pretty recent so I believe I can comment on a few common topics:

1. the million dollar question, is replica safe to ride?

There is no simple answer for this actually, it depends. If your aliexpress replica is only $200 USD including handlebar, you tell me, do you think it is safe to ride?
However I can confidently tell you if you are buying a $600+ USD replica, there won't be any major safety issues, it is not like you ride your replica normally and it snapped in half immediately, unless you are a heavy rider, but I am pretty sure even branded bikes aren't gonna be that safe if you are heavy, because physics, you cannot have something that is light enough yet still be able to withstand a tremendous load.

I got a friend who has a real Time frame and the front fork snapped in half when he was descending down a hill, spent a month or two in the hospital, he was like 90kg I think? So yeah, famous brand doesn't guarantee safety, or maybe just bad luck, who knows, good thing is Time gave him a replacement for free so if you buy legit that's your advantage.


2. Is replica going to be as good as the real thing performance wise?

Absolutely not, but is it close? I would say yes, replica tends to feel less stiff, a bit heavier and a little bit sluggish. If I really need to give a direct comparison, I will say replica has 90% of the performance, in fact, we all sort of know the answer, if you get dropped, problem's on you, not the bike. Honestly if you are not a racer, don't bother, I don't really think a racer would consider buying replica anyway.


3. How's the paint in the replica?
Pretty good, if you don't tell anyone that is a replica I doubt your local club rider is able to tell the difference unless they also have experiecne with replica. However, it is not perfect, you can't really expect a perfect paint with that price if you really know the process & equipment required to get the paint on the frame.



4. You buy replica? SHAME ON YOU
Yes I am a bad person, I own $10k+ USD worth of cameras & lens from Sony yet go cheap on bikes, I have no respect to legit brand, plz don't be like me.




Btw, if you are not a DIY person nor got the time, probably not so wise to buy replica because there are going to be a lot of little things that need your DIY capabilities.

10
Probably the best take on the carbon layers that they used, for that price range for sure. We will see in the end how that goes. Do you have a picture of your bike tssy5?

I know it will bring controversy and that many people, especially on this form, don't like it.

What an analogy, but I get where you are coming from. For your information I'm not selling this bike as a real one, nor do I try to sleep with someone else to take that identity. See it as a cheap kit car on a Pontiac Fiero base. If you copy a Lamborghini with a kit on the base of a Pontiac Fiero, it won't drive like a Lambo, it won't sound like a Lambo, it just looks like it.

I believe that this fake Factor also won't drive like a real Factor, I'll get Elite Drive wheels, probably the Black Inc wheels are much better, the stiffness in the frame and handlebars will be much less than the original. The original has every where Ceramicspeed bearings, I don't. At a kit car it's quite obvious for the trained eye, I think it will also be obvious for the factor that it's a replica (for the trained eye).
And at this point I can't get rid of the stickers anymore, sorry.

Matte black with no logo, pretty stealthy

11
If people know their stuff about wheels, this particular 2:1 lacing pattern Campagnolo called "G3" requires high quality rim that is very stiff, otherwise the spoke could break easily (or the nipples depending on the tension).

If you are looking for this pattern in a cheap Chinese wheelset, my answer is don't risk it.

12
I've purchased it on Aliexpress (store: taiwan factory bike parts Store - model New Model Fasterway Ostro) and I could choose between any factor color scheme (painted or the stickers are under the paint), I doubted the one without any paint or just the clear paint that you could see the carbon layers. I know a lot of people here don't like replicas or placing a brand name on a copied frame, but in the end, I still did it, because I liked it (sorry).

I doubted also the long ten that Serge-K has, but I believe the rear is still a bit different, I think the rear tubes are a bit smaller in diameter than the long ten, but that opinion is just based on pictures that I saw so I don't know for sure + there is not a big price difference between those frames. I considered basically a lot of frames, like everyone does. I checked all bike sizes and geometries and my personal preference in looks and this was, what came out.

Difficult to say, it's my first build and I watched a lot of comments and threads here and YouTube clips from various builders/YouTubers. For my liking is the paint job very well done, I was expecting worse, to be honest. The placement of the calipers is fine for what I have and fits perfectly so that should be fine too. And I don't have a small camera to look into the bike so I have no idea what it in looks like inside other than the BB part.

For me the BB threads look good too, if I compare them to some clips that I saw from Hambini's YouTube channel, so overall I'm quite pleased. The handlebar is a copy of black inc. and I need to sand it a bit, the inside of the stem where the wires enter that it's not too sharp but I have the feeling everyone is doing this.

In the end, I think it was carbon T1000 UD instead of T1100 but okay good enough for me, I'm just an amateur, no pro by any means, so I also think I won't break the d-shaped tube from the front fork. I won't generate that much force I'm afraid, so I do not foresee any problems but I will let you know, once it's finished and I actually drove a decent amount of km or miles.

I also came across a Ostro VAM replica frame without logo in size 52 for around $500 USD. I don't have any proof but I personally don't believe they really give you T1000 / T1100 for a cheap frame like this, even if they have it is probably just a single layer of T1000, which is pretty much useless (the western brands do it like this too when they claim they used T1000 btw).

Full build is 8kg including pedals, it feels a bit less stiff than my Giant TCR Advanced 2 but my TCR creaks like hell in the BB area when riding uphill, yet this supposed to be cheap quality aliexpress frame has no creaking issues.

Bad thing about this replica is that the little parts are not high quality, which means you would need to get yourself some titanium bolts, there is also no manual whatsoever so you would need to figure out those little issues yourself such as finding the right size and length for the bolts, could be pain in the ass if you are not a DIY person.

The paint is really great for this price, it is not perfect but you can hardly notice those minor issues without knowing where to look.

13
Even the most recommended frames don't always produced with the same quality. The good thing about Chinese brands is that they are cheaper, so you can always keep trying different frame until you find one that works the best for you.

Having the mentality of looking for the best frame / brand isn't great, even for the well-known western brands.

14
Tripeak is a Taiwanese company, generally speaking the products they made are great just like FSA and Token.
Better to get a steel one, ceramic is not worth it, unless you race.

15
Road Bike Frames, Wheels & Components / Re: Winspace T1550 Build
« on: February 16, 2024, 05:46:32 AM »
Hey @Macedingle, just wondering the black friday deal you used 2450$ USD for the Frameset+bar+wheels did you also include an extra 10% discount code?

They are offering me 2580$ USD now but with SE wheels and no extra 10% discount code...still debating if I should pull the trigger or wait a bit more.

Thanks

I am not the person you are tagging but afaik the SE wheels is pretty much the non-SE version with steel bearings, there is nothing wrong with steel bearings and probably better in terms of durability and long term performance.
If their offer is $2450 with SE wheels I would take it, but I would wait a bit if it is $2580 to see if they are going to have a sale soon.

Pages: [1] 2