Carbonda FM909-120mm vs HongFu FM358

Started by HardTail29, September 19, 2026, 03:23:12 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

HardTail29

Hey all, I'm trying to decide between these two, they have similar geometry(I'd be getting size M), both are 120mm front and rear. Both have space for two bottles

Which one would you choose and why?

And if anybody has owned or ridden both or either of those, what did you like or dislike about them ?

Thanks!!


federic000

hard to tell, the 909 is a little old now, cinematics and geo are not as new as the 358, don't forget though that 909 is an original OEM design while the FM358 is a carbon copy of previous Canyon Lux Trail (so this also no longer up-to-date). As china-lovers XC-ists we are struggling, nobody is investing in XC frames, there's old stuff or badly made clones only. I'll keep my FM936 until it breaks.   

Beison8000

Quote from: federic000 on September 21, 2026, 10:10:19 AMhard to tell, the 909 is a little old now, cinematics and geo are not as new as the 358, don't forget though that 909 is an original OEM design while the FM358 is a carbon copy of previous Canyon Lux Trail (so this also no longer up-to-date). As china-lovers XC-ists we are struggling, nobody is investing in XC frames, there's old stuff or badly made clones only. I'll keep my FM936 until it breaks.   


Hmm I am also looking for something.  That's why I make my first post here actually.  The Hongfu FM138 and Spcycle M868 seem to be newer, especially with the Spcycle being based on the pretty modern Orbea geometry.

I get worried when I read about some of the quality control issues though, which I guess I can find on just about every one of the Chinese brands. ...But then again you can find the same issues on the western brands too so maybe it's not that big an issue.

What are your thoughts if you need to build up a bike for next year's racing season?  What would you do with the current crop of offerings?

acedeuce802

Quote from: federic000 on September 21, 2026, 10:10:19 AMhard to tell, the 909 is a little old now, cinematics and geo are not as new as the 358, don't forget though that 909 is an original OEM design while the FM358 is a carbon copy of previous Canyon Lux Trail (so this also no longer up-to-date). As china-lovers XC-ists we are struggling, nobody is investing in XC frames, there's old stuff or badly made clones only. I'll keep my FM936 until it breaks.   

what exactly is old about the 909, other than it being released 5 years ago?  it has a steeper STA and longer reach than the 358, and otherwise nearly identical geo.

rancor

Quote from: acedeuce802 on November 17, 2026, 04:54:26 PMwhat exactly is old about the 909, other than it being released 5 years ago?  it has a steeper STA and longer reach than the 358, and otherwise nearly identical geo.

Suspension design is just a bit old. Lower anti-squat then most modern bikes especially with larger 34-36T chain-rings. It ends up bobbing on the peddles and is generally a softer bike compared to modern race bikes, it doesn't feel like it has as very direct power transfer. On the geo side its stack is a bit low and its head-tube angle is a few degrees steeper than 2026 bikes. Its otherwise a very modern geo. Due to is suspension and longer rear center it still has awesome grip when climbing and is a great descender but i wouldn't call it sharp.

federic000

I wasn't referring to geo specifically even though Rancor said it better in the previous post, but mostly to aesthetics, I don't ask for the cleanliness of the 2027 spark of course (there's an abyss) but the rear triangle and suspension links are looking very old nowadays, I still like more the 936 than 909.

Zeus

Quote from: HardTail29 on September 19, 2026, 03:23:12 PMHey all, I'm trying to decide between these two, they have similar geometry(I'd be getting size M), both are 120mm front and rear. Both have space for two bottles

Which one would you choose and why?

And if anybody has owned or ridden both or either of those, what did you like or dislike about them ?

Thanks!!

Hi

I really like my 909 with a 120mm fork and 105mm in the rear (ish) its the 100 link, but I sqeezed in a 165*42,5 shock :-)
Pedals really well and lots of grip, up and down. Its a bit longer (in XL) than the 958.
Its not old, and I want a new one, cause I chrashed it near the bb. It held op for 4 years though :-)
Have there not been issues with the 958, fitting the shock and stuff?

Cheers