Author Topic: Replacement for an edge 530?  (Read 36129 times)

cramy

Re: Replacement for an edge 530?
« Reply #30 on: July 23, 2025, 07:40:42 AM »
so Serge, finally which one did you choose?

kbernstein

Re: Replacement for an edge 530?
« Reply #31 on: August 06, 2025, 01:46:14 PM »
Hijacking the thread to review my new unit
I got a good deal locally on the latest IGPSport binavi
Since I'm a slut for computers (bodycount of 13, my longest running until now had been the IGS630, got it 14 months ago which is a record since I started cycling) I figured it would be just a little upgrade over it, bigger screen, touchscreen, new UI and thats about all i expected.
It's a huge step up in every way. I never expected it to love it this much and even some areas I didn't think could be improved much have been significantly overhauled
Touchscreen is extremely responsive, rerouting is pretty good, display is bright, iClimb is perfect (always starts exactly where I would put the start, always ends exactly at the highest point, plus great UI overlaid on the map instead of a dedicated screen), map layer is a lot better (actually easy to tell roads, gravel roads and singletracks apart), much faster boot time, very fast GPS (zero jumps and autopause AS SOON as i stop/go as opposed to 2-3 seconds on every other unit i tried. the pause button might as well be removed, I don't think i manually paused yet)
I have 3 rides on it so far totaling 9 hours and 50 minutes and the battery went from 100% to 63%, always gravel riding with a course loaded (and map page displayed 80% of the time), 3 sensors connected and auto brightness in summer, BUT smart track enabled (only noticed today because intervals.icu told me but data is good). So almost worst case scenario and on track for almost 30 hours, not too bad
I also really like all the analysis and summary screens on the main menu. I have not tried segments yet.
Being nitpicky, the only quirks I've noticed was the map disappearing for a split second when recalculating a route, "taillight battery" not working with my L508 (magene's fault?), and today's peak 1s power being 1850 at the time I almost fell in the mud because time xc pedals are fucking garbage. (powermeter's fault?)

I know the MSRP and size is going to be a dealbreaker for many if not most wanting something basic, but it's a seriously great unit. It's not just magene's C606 being put to shame, it's also garmin that should be shaking

PS: Serge, if you want to try out either, I'll be near morez next month if you're nearby
« Last Edit: August 06, 2025, 01:48:54 PM by kbernstein »

zealot128

Re: Replacement for an edge 530?
« Reply #32 on: August 22, 2025, 04:17:48 AM »
Had the iGPSport 630S brought from a Chinese friend 1m ago, for about the same price, in a bundle including their VS800 light EUR 144 (same price as the computer only, so why not! - The light is quite bright, good battery 4000mAh about 4-8h in medium/"low", couple of mount options but has no good cut-off for every-day riding, but good for the night rides in the forest nevertheless).

So far, ok:
- Back from Wahoo, I needed to change the mount inlays because of 90ยบ Rotation again (Garmin style)
- Needs the phone app, which is like, ... yeah okish. Translations only English, no
  - No issues connecting to the gps unit and their radar
- 👍🏻 No issues in connecting BT/Ant+ devices
- 👍🏻Battery is good so far, esp. compared to Wahoo, I used the initial charge that come from the box a couple of rides,
- 👎🏻no Intervals.icu integration / harder to get trainings on it, only way seem to be Trainer-Roads
- 👍🏻Strava/Komoot Route and finished ride sync works - occasionally it syncs automatically, but usually i need to open the phone app - not as nice as Wahoo though (You always have to copy to their "Roadbook" first, Then sync to Device, Then start on Device, Wahoo just 1 Click)
- 👎🏻Tons of default pages which needed some work to trim down via App
- 👎🏻Compared to Wahoo Bolt 2 the screen and map is slightly worse to grep, especially map is okish I would say, It shows the maps, but it's hard to navigate on it. Also on bright sunlight from above screen is hard to see, because of reflections (not with bolt)
- Similar to Bolt no touchscreen, but a little different button system which needed some time to get used to.
- 👍🏻More pleasent "beep" sound for radar warnings than Wahoo.


-> Conclusion: Good device for this price point, esp. now that the new Wahoo bolt is 2x of it... I really liked the Bolt, but only battery time was something that never be too satisfactory, and now the battery of the Bolt seem to slowly fade, so this is clearly a good alternative device for me. For Trainingrides I will keep the Bolt though, like the interfaces and Intervals.icu better here.

I plan to buy the Chinese one I mentioned above when I get to France, so I can easily return it if I don't like it. I've been using my Fenix (on my wrist) to track the rides in the meantime, and not seeing bike metrics during a ride has been interesting as an experiment.
I think I'm done with Garmin the analytics really aren't great, I resent them for not improving over time. Latest pet peeves: I do a 4h ride, hard, training effect 5.0, the watch calls it recovery. Once it's uploaded the status changes, but the watch has decided to be stupid and it annoys me. And I find unacceptable that they don't compute a training load unless you have HR (power without HR). A long list of small things that makes me want to try something new.


Edit 11 Aug 25: i just ordered the igpsport 630S, cost me 156 eur all in via Alix. my alternatives were garmin devices that were either 150 eur at the cheapest, or much more. Usual garmin comps are expensive. In this price range, there was the bryton 510E but it was 35% more expensive. The 630S, on paper, does all i need in the form factor i like. To be continued...
My review aggreation site and Bike Builder: https://mybike.parts YT: https://youtube.com/@mybikeparts

raisinberry777

Re: Replacement for an edge 530?
« Reply #33 on: August 28, 2025, 02:02:22 AM »
I'm currently going through a similar process with a dying Garmin 530 (at least it's draining lots of battery while switched off, like 20% per day), so I've thrown caution to the wind and bought the iGPSport BiNavi, was about $220USD before taxes in the current AliExpress sale. Didn't feel like Garmin deserved my money again... yet.

Seems like probably the only major feature I'd be missing compared to the 530 is Strava live segments (doesn't look like iGPSport supports this?), but then I remembered that I generally find it pretty annoying on the 530 anyway, Anyway, a couple of weeks and we'll see how we go.

carbonazza

Re: Replacement for an edge 530?
« Reply #34 on: August 28, 2025, 07:22:58 AM »
I'm not a kommard anymore so I didn't try it, but I saw the IGS800 has live segments.

I ride the IGS800 and K2. I love them both. And have excellent user support.
Unfortunately not perfect. But when I compare to my Garmin friends, who can't get their gpx at so many rides, I'm happy.

The big pluses of the IGS800 are the battery life, and the screen size, and readability under the sun(although not good when mixed with trees in woods) and richer software.
The two big downs are the contrast of their map: grey on grey is invisible, with sunglasses it's even worse, and it is always like 3 sec late at junctions.

They had a very slow update cycle on bugs/improvements but now under SRAM they are back delivering continuously.
The big down for me, and the reason of my IGS800 purchase, is when the climbing ladder appear over the map, your position on the map(the direction arrow), disappear below the ladder, making it impossible to know where to go many times.

Some other annoyances of the IGS800:
The trip from a Komoot route to start riding is uselessly tedious, and could be automated
The protective case is a joke

And some annoyance of the K2:
Let it dry before charging after a wet ride, the plug will melt inside.
However they quite nicely replaced mine 3 times under warranty, even if I was once out of the period!

raisinberry777

Re: Replacement for an edge 530?
« Reply #35 on: August 28, 2025, 07:01:03 PM »
Well, RIP me because I didn't see this gplama video on the sticky watts issue:

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DMZEgSwS2x0/?igsh=MTc5cndwc3l4aDRkeA==

... deary dear. Let's see how we go then, it's already shipped so might as well make the most of it!

IL_EH_75

Re: Replacement for an edge 530?
« Reply #36 on: January 17, 2026, 01:51:41 AM »
Hi.

My Garmin 520 battery is going to dead soon and I'm looking for a new bike GPS with similar options as 520 has without being Garmin.

Most important:

Battery life.
Connection with Strava and intervals.
All kind of sensor connection as Hr, powermeter, Di2.
Open to try any Chinese GPS brand.

Any suggestion?

Ludo

Re: Replacement for an edge 530?
« Reply #37 on: January 17, 2026, 05:27:10 AM »
The new Magene?